Propane Vs Natural Gas Fire Pit: Pros, Cons and How to Choose

This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.

You’re on the hunt for the perfect fire pit, but you’re stuck on a key decision: propane or natural gas? This guide will help you weigh the pros and cons of each, touching on aspects like heat output, installation, cost, and maintenance.

By the end, you’ll have a clear idea of which fire pit fuel type suits your needs best. So, let’s jump right in to help you decide between a propane vs natural gas fire pit.

What is the Difference Between Propane and Natural Gas?

propane vs gas fire pit

The main difference between propane and natural gas is that propane, being a refined form of natural gas, burns hotter and cleaner, but natural gas is often cheaper and provides a continuous fuel supply.

When considering propane vs natural gas heat, propane’s higher burning temperature could be a deciding factor. However, in terms of propane vs natural gas cost, natural gas typically wins with lower prices.

In terms of availability, propane often has the upper hand, being easily stored and transported. Installation can be a bit more complex with natural gas as it often requires professional help, unlike propane. It is also a permanent fix, so moving your fire pit isn’t as easy.

Maintenance for both is necessary, but natural gas systems might need more professional check-ups due to their continuous supply.

Pros and Cons of a Propane Fire Pit

Let’s delve into your topic of interest, the pros and cons of propane, and how it impacts your choices for a home heating solution.

Propane, a clean-burning fuel, offers many benefits but also presents some challenges.

Here’s your quick comparison:

Higher heat output than natural gasMore expensive than natural gas
No installation requirementsTank can be visible with some fire pits
Having to buy or refill propane tanks

Pros and Cons of a Natural Gas Fire Pit

natural gas vs propane fire pit

Considering the pros and cons of natural gas, it’s cheaper than propane, but the installation can be more complex, involving running gas pipes and potentially adding a quick connect box. This isn’t a task you’d want to tackle on your own; professional assistance is recommended.

On the bright side, once installed, natural gas is readily available, providing a constant fuel source for your fire pit. This ensures a steady heat output, making your evenings more comfortable.

Cost EffectiveComplex Installation
Constant Fuel AvailabilityFixed Location
Steady Heat OutputProfessional Assistance Required
Minimal Maintenance

However, the environmental impact is a point of contention. Natural gas burns cleaner than wood but it’s still a fossil fuel, emitting greenhouse gases. Ultimately, your choice depends on your budget, availability, and environmental considerations.

Converting a Fire Pit at a Later Stage

It’s essential to know that converting your fire pit from propane to natural gas, or vice versa after it’s already been installed can be done. Here are some key points to consider:

  • Converting options: Retrofitting kits are available, but compatibility with your current system is essential.
  • Retrofitting Process: This involves removing the current burner system, replacing it with a compatible one, and connecting it to the new fuel source.
  • Cost Considerations: Conversion may involve purchasing new equipment and hiring a professional, adding to the expense.
  • Fuel Availability: Ensure the new fuel type, whether propane or natural gas, is readily available in your area.
  • Installation Requirements: Both conversions require adherence to safety standards, possibly requiring professional installation.

Propane vs Natural Gas Fire Pit Safety

propane vs natural gas fire pit safety

You’re probably wondering about the safety aspects of using a propane or natural gas fire pit in your backyard. Safety precautions, gas leak detection, ventilation requirements, fire pit maintenance, and emergency shutdown procedures are all essential for a safe and enjoyable experience.

Propane Fire PitNatural Gas Fire Pit
Requires regular checks for leaksRequires professional installation
Easy shutdown in case of emergencyRequires a well-ventilated space
Maintenance involves regular refillRegular maintenance checks are necessary

Frequently Asked Questions

What Precautions Should Be Taken While Installing a Propane or Natural Gas Fire Pit?

Ensure installation safety by checking material compatibility and picking a safe pit location. Consider ventilation needs to avoid gas buildup. Use reliable ignition systems. Always follow manufacturer’s instructions or hire a professional.

What Is the Environmental Impact of Using Propane Vs Natural Gas for a Fire Pit?

Considering emission comparisons, propane burns cleaner than natural gas. However, natural gas is more efficient, reducing your carbon footprint. Both have minimal health implications, but sustainability aspects favor natural gas due to its abundance.

How Does Weather Affect the Performance of Propane and Natural Gas Fire Pits?

In extreme weather, both propane and natural gas fire pits’ performance can fluctuate. Cold climates affect propane more, while rainy weather and wind conditions could impact both. So, consider weather durability when choosing.

Can I Switch From Propane to Natural Gas or Vice Versa on the Same Fire Pit if I Move Houses?

You can switch, but consider conversion costs, installation complexities, and equipment compatibility. Check gas availability in your new location. Always prioritize safety measures when dealing with gas conversions. Consult with a professional for advice.


Your choice between a propane or natural gas fire pit depends on your specific needs.

Propane offers easy installation and flexibility, while natural gas provides larger flames and potential cost-effectiveness over time.

Weigh the pros and cons carefully, and remember, you can convert your fire pit later if needed. Make the choice that best fits with your budget, and enhances your outdoor living space.

Scroll to Top
Special offer for our visitors

Get your Fire Pits Free Guide

We will never send you spam. By signing up for this you agree with our privacy policy and to receive regular updates via email in regards to industry news and promotions